Copyright © 2026 Discover. All rights reserved

All views, information or opinions expressed in Discover Brighton are solely those of individuals involved and do not represent the opinions of any entity whatsoever, including the businesses mentioned within this publication and those to which are affected.

Pommy’s New York Pizza review

30 Jul, 2025

Does Brighton and Hove need another pizza joint? The short answer is yes, read on to find out why… 

The name ‘Pommy’s’ is derived from the word ‘Pomodoro’ the Italian word for tomato, found at the heart of every great pizza. What sets Pommy’s apart from other pizzerias in the city is its distinctive New York style. Expect a thinner, foldable base, perfect for eating on the go. 

Italian owners Ricardo and Stephan explained that New York pizza is not American, but in fact, Roman. The pizza’s origins date back to 1905, when Naples-born Gennaro Lombardi rocked up and opened the very first pizzeria in Manhattan, bringing the beloved Italian staple to American workers one slice at a time. Pommy’s embraces this ethos and you too can now buy decent pizza one slice at a time. 

So what does it taste like? Ricardo presented a platter with different slices for us to sample and I got stuck into my first (and favourite) Cacio & Pepe, featuring ricotta, mozzarella, parmesan and pecorino. The team makes the white sauce base in house and as a self-confessed cheese addict, I adored the creamy ricotta and generous grated parmesan and pecorino combo. The base is indeed foldable and thin, and satisfyingly chewy.

I’ve always wanted to try vodka sauce and my wish was granted with the next slice, simply named Vodka, featuring the aforementioned vodka sauce, mozzarella, basil and parmesan. It boasted a delicate creamy tomato flavour, and the vodka enriches the tomato sauce to great effect. 

Finally, we tried a slice of Grandma (never thought I’d ever be writing those words…), which is square cut and much denser than the other pizza offered. A rich tomato sauce covered the top and the pizza is characterised by its cheese first, sauce second approach, just like Grandma used to make. 

The verdict? Pommy’s is a slice of New York with an Italian soul in the heart of Brighton. With something for everyone, a relaxed vibe, and one of the first new venues to open in the revitalised Imperial Arcade, it’s well worth a visit.

www.pommyspizza.com

Follow us:

More from Discover Brighton:

From Brighton to Blade Runner

From Brighton to Blade Runner

From Brighton to Blade Runner: Local Jeweller Creates Red-Carpet Piece for Sci-Fi Star   Local actor Sam C. Wilson commissions Brighton-based jeweller Beth Chaplin of Rose Honey to create a bespoke silver necklace for the premiere of Blade Runner 2099....

FareShare Sussex & Surrey

FareShare Sussex & Surrey

FareShare Sussex & Surrey calls for Tesco Food Collection volunteers as food insecurity rises FareShare Sussex & Surrey is urgently calling for volunteers to support the Tesco Food Collection this November. The appeal comes as food insecurity continues to...

Try somewhere new this NEWvember

Try somewhere new this NEWvember

59 Brighton and Sussex venues unveil exclusive offers to invite diners to try somewhere new this NEWvember   From £8.50 lunches to sharing feasts and winter seafront experiences, NEWvember launches today with exclusive food and drink offers across the region....

Brighton & Hove’s Artists Open Houses

Brighton & Hove’s Artists Open Houses

Brighton & Hove’s Artists Open Houses Winter Festival returns, offering a unique alternative to online and high-street Christmas shopping and commercial Christmas markets   Artists Open Houses Winter Festival returns, with artists’ homes, studios and...